Diggit vs ReplyGuy: Who Posts Your Reddit Replies?
Published: October 17, 2026 · 5 min read
ReplyGuy and Diggit both find Reddit conversations where your product could help and write a reply. The difference is who posts it. ReplyGuy's own FAQ says that for Reddit it uses purchased accounts, which it emails to you after you subscribe, and its pricing counts each reply "posted and verified". Diggit drafts the reply and you post it yourself, from your own account, or not at all.
That one difference decides most of the comparison. If you want replies going out without doing the posting, ReplyGuy is built for that. If you're worried about posting promotional replies from accounts that aren't yours, at a time when Reddit is removing spam within seconds and banning accounts by the million, Diggit keeps the posting decision, and the account, yours.
We make Diggit, so read this as a vendor's comparison. We've tried to state ReplyGuy's strengths as plainly as our own; the sources for its facts are listed at the end.
ReplyGuy vs Diggit at a glance
| ReplyGuy | Diggit | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Pro $49/month (5 keywords, 100 credits); Business $99/month (25 keywords, 300 credits); Enterprise $199/month (100 keywords, 1,000 credits). Yearly: $249, $499 or $999. A posted reply costs 3 credits, a surfaced comment 1, a DM 5. 3-day trial. | $19, $39 or $69/month (Starter, Growth, Pro); annual billing gets 2 months free. Free preview scan before signup. |
| What you give it | Keywords (its AI suggests some for your product) | Your website URL. It suggests the subreddits your buyers use |
| Who posts the reply | On Reddit, ReplyGuy posts from purchased accounts it provides. On X, you edit and post it yourself | You do, from your own account. Diggit never posts for you |
| Product mentions | Replies "mention your product when relevant" | Decided by the subreddit's rules: no mention where they restrict self-promotion, otherwise at most one, disclosed as yours |
| Subreddit rules | Not mentioned on its site | Warns you when a subreddit's rules restrict self-promotion or AI-written content |
| How posts are ranked | Its AI picks "high quality, recent, and relevant" posts that match your keywords | Every post in your subreddits scored 10-100 for buying intent against what you sell |
| Platforms | Reddit and X (Twitter) | Reddit only |
| Proof of work | Screenshot proof of every posted reply | Not applicable: you post, so you see it |
| Try before paying | 3-day trial; payments refundable within 7 days if the product is unused | Free preview scan of your own market, without creating an account |
When to pick ReplyGuy instead
- You want replies posted for you and don't want to do it yourself, and you accept that on Reddit they come from accounts ReplyGuy provides rather than yours.
- You also want to reply on X. Diggit covers Reddit only.
- You want screenshot proof and reports of every reply that went out.
When Diggit is the better fit
- You want replies posted from your own account, with your history behind them, and nothing going out without you.
- You want the subreddit's rules to decide whether your product gets mentioned, and to be warned before you post somewhere that bans promotion or AI-written content.
- You want buyers ranked by intent, not just posts that contain your keywords, so your replies go where they're most likely to land.
- You want to see results from your own market before paying: the preview is free and needs no account. Plans start at $19/month.
FAQ
Does ReplyGuy post on Reddit for you?
Yes, according to its own FAQ: "For Reddit: We use purchased accounts that will be provided to you via email within a few days of subscribing." For X, it suggests replies and you post them yourself.
How much does ReplyGuy cost?
As of October 2026 its pricing page lists Pro at $49/month, Business at $99/month and Enterprise at $199/month, or $249, $499 and $999 a year. Its homepage shows different limits and yearly prices, plus an Agency plan at $499/month, so check both before you buy.
Does Diggit post replies for me?
No. Diggit drafts replies and DMs in your tone, and you review, edit and post them yourself from your own Reddit account.
Is it safe to post promotional replies on Reddit?
It depends on the community. Many subreddits ban self-promotion or AI-written content outright, and Reddit's 2026 spam enforcement acts within seconds. Read each subreddit's rules, say plainly when you're recommending your own product, and post from an account with real history.
Try it on your own market
The fastest way to compare is with your own subreddits. Paste your website URL into Diggit and the free preview scan shows you real posts from your market, each scored for buying intent, before you pay or create an account.
Comparing other tools? See all our comparisons and alternatives.
Related reading: